Review: First Impressions: A Novel of Old Books, Unexpected Love, and Jane Austen by Charlie Lovett

• Hardcover: 320 pages
• Publisher: Viking Adult; 1ST edition (October 16, 2014)
• ISBN: 9780525427247
• Source: Publisher

Sophie Collingwood inherits a London home after her Uncle Bertram passes away. Both were avid book lovers, Sophie recalls time spent in his library discussing their love of books. Unfortunately, her uncle’s library is sold off to recover debt and Sophie finds herself at a loss as to how she will ever replace Bertram’s library.  So, she seeks solace in the one thing that comforts her – books- and begins working at an antiquarian bookstore she and Bertram frequented.

When two customers are simultaneously asking for the same obscure book, Sophie’s interest is piqued.  She immediately begins an investigation into the background of the book, the second edition of Little Book of Allegories by Richard Mansfield.   What she discovers might tarnish the name of her favorite author, Jane Austen, and immerse her in a dangerous and thrilling mystery that threatens her life.

Told in dual narratives, alternating between Sophie’s hunt for the allusive volume (and two alluring suitors) and Jane Austen’s friendship with cleric Richard Mansfield, First Impressions: A Novel of Old Books, Unexpected Love, and Jane Austen is a charming novel about the love of books and reading and the enduring power of family and friendship.  While I typically go out of my way to avoid retellings involving my favorite classic author, Jane Austen, I was compelled to read this one. Perhaps it was the hint of mystery that grabbed my attention or the raves of the author’s previous work. No matter the reason, I quickly became enamored with this novel, a true tribute to books.

While I appreciated nearly every aspect of the book, from the dual narratives to the fictional retelling of Jane Austen’s process in writing some of her most classic novels, there were some things about the book that nearly drove me insane. The “relationships” Sophie formed with one of the characters seemed forced and unnecessary.  Frankly, I nearly  threw the book when I saw what was to happen. That said, I can easily overlook it if I weigh it against the many positives. The concept of love as a whole, not romantic but…familial, was heartwarming and rewarding.

I realize I’m quite vague in my summary and description of this book. This, of course, is intentional as it should be the reader themselves who uncover the wealth of beauty contained within the pages of this novel. First Impressions: A Novel of Old Books, Unexpected Love, and Jane Austen is a must-read for a variety of readers, from fans of Jane Austen and her work to general lovers of books. The underlying mystery will take hold of readers’ interest quite immediately, only releasing its hold when the truth is eloquently and expertly revealed.  A perfect gift for that reader in your life (or  yourself!), this is a book that will be cherished and appreciated by many. Highly recommended.